Hong Kong News

Nonpartisan, Noncommercial, unconstrained.
Monday, Mar 04, 2024

Why some experts question need for foreign lawyer ban in Hong Kong security cases

Why some experts question need for foreign lawyer ban in Hong Kong security cases

Some legal experts say city’s efforts should be spent on strengthening procedures to keep confidential information from emerging during sensitive trials.

Foreign lawyers do handle national security or sovereignty cases in other jurisdictions and a ban on them by Hong Kong would make it an outlier, according to legal experts, with some arguing the city’s efforts should instead be spent on strengthening procedures to keep confidential information from emerging during sensitive trials.

While acknowledging the uniqueness of Hong Kong’s situation as many countries were not as open as the city in allowing non-locally qualified lawyers to practise in the first place, experts both at home and abroad on Thursday questioned the reasoning behind drawing such a line in the sand.

Hong Kong leader John Lee Ka-chiu on Monday asked Beijing to interpret the national security law after the city’s top court upheld a ruling allowing British barrister Timothy Owen to defend media tycoon Jimmy Lai Chee-ying against charges of collusion with foreign forces in his coming trial.

British barrister Timothy Owen (right).

Lee argued that the unprecedented move was needed as there was no effective means to ensure overseas lawyers would not have a conflict of interest because of their nationality and that they would not be controlled by foreign agencies.

Professor Johannes Chan Man-mun, former law dean of the University of Hong Kong, said in general there was no restrictions on the type of cases foreign lawyers could handle if they were admitted for litigation purposes.

“In international law disputes, it is fairly common to have foreign lawyers representing a country, even in matters of great political sensitivity,” Chan said.

He noted that Singapore and Malaysia were represented by leading lawyers from Britain in a dispute over the sovereignty of a few islands before the International Court of Justice some years ago.

Malaysia hired barristers Sir Elihu Lauterpacht QC and James Crawford QC, whereas Singapore was represented by Ian Brownlie QC alongside a number of eminent international lawyers from France, he added.

In Singapore, king’s counsel might be appointed to cases where local expertise was insufficient.

“This can be in any area but happens very rarely since the Singapore bar is mature,” said Professor Tan Cheng Han of the National University of Singapore’s law school.

The United States was more restrictive in regards to foreign lawyers, as they were generally not allowed to represent clients in litigation unless they had become members of a US Bar Association, experts said.

“There is no ‘ad hoc’ admission to act as the counsel for a client, particularly in a criminal matter,” said Ryan Mitchell, assistant professor of the Chinese University of Hong Kong’s law faculty.

“That said, neither are there specific rules governing ‘national security’ cases that would make them any more strict than other cases.”

In Britain, a mechanism was in place to appoint “special advocates” on national security cases under which they could not communicate what they saw in full to an affected party.

Established by the Counter Terrorism and Security Act 2015, special advocates are security-vetted lawyers representing the interests of parties excluded from national security-related hearings.

“The nationality of a lawyer may be a reason not to appoint him as a special advocate but, as far as I know, there is no rule barring foreign nationals, such as a lawyer from Canada or Australia, from taking up such cases if they are otherwise a good security risk,” said Philip Dykes SC, a former chairman of the Bar Association.

The crux of the matter was whether the lawyer could be trusted and was not an unacceptable security risk, rather than his or her nationality or residency, Dykes said.

The problem could be reconciled if Hong Kong had a similar special advocate scheme, in which foreign counsel could appear “subject to him or her not necessarily seeing evidence of major national security concerns”, he added.

One of the government’s core arguments to seek an interpretation in banning foreign lawyers from sensitive trials was that it was “impossible” to ensure they would comply with Article 63 of the national security law requiring them not to divulge state or commercial secrets, or personal details from the case.

The proposed interpretation would only target lawyers registered overseas, not foreign ones listed in Hong Kong, the city leader said.

But Thomas Kellogg, executive director of the Centre for Asian Law at Georgetown University in the US, said the general practice globally was to focus on procedures for keeping key national security-related information confidential, rather than on limiting foreign lawyers from taking part.

“The government hasn’t really made clear why such procedures wouldn’t be sufficient in this case,” he said.

Chan, who remains the first and so far only honorary senior counsel in Hong Kong, said it was “obviously unsound” for the government to introduce a simple rule restricting foreign lawyers from representing a client in all national security cases.

“After all, not all national security law cases would involve state secrets. We have quite a number of national security cases already where there is no shred or suggestion of any state secrets,” he said.

“If the prosecution is to allege that state secrets are involved, they would have the burden to establish such a case and show why the usual duty of confidentiality is insufficient to safeguard state secrets. This could always be dealt with on a case-by-case basis.”


Related Articles

Hong Kong News
It's always the people with the dirty hands pointing their fingers
Paper straws found to contain long-lasting and potentially toxic chemicals - study
FTX's Bankman-Fried headed for jail after judge revokes bail
Blackrock gets half a trillion dollar deal to rebuild Ukraine
Steve Jobs' Son Launches Venture Capital Firm With $200 Million For Cancer Treatments
Google reshuffles Assistant unit, lays off some staffers, to 'supercharge' products with A.I.
End of Viagra? FDA approved a gel against erectile dysfunction
UK sanctions Russians judges over dual British national Kara-Murza's trial
US restricts visa-free travel for Hungarian passport holders because of security concerns
America's First New Nuclear Reactor in Nearly Seven Years Begins Operations
Southeast Asia moves closer to economic unity with new regional payments system
Political leader from South Africa, Julius Malema, led violent racist chants at a massive rally on Saturday
Today Hunter Biden’s best friend and business associate, Devon Archer, testified that Joe Biden met in Georgetown with Russian Moscow Mayor's Wife Yelena Baturina who later paid Hunter Biden $3.5 million in so called “consulting fees”
'I am not your servant': IndiGo crew member, passenger get into row over airline meal
Singapore Carries Out First Execution of a Woman in Two Decades Amid Capital Punishment Debate
Spanish Citizenship Granted to Iranian chess player who removed hijab
US Senate Republican Mitch McConnell freezes up, leaves press conference
Speaker McCarthy says the United States House of Representatives is getting ready to impeach Joe Biden.
San Francisco car crash
This camera man is a genius
3D ad in front of Burj Khalifa
Next level gaming
BMW driver…
Google testing journalism AI. We are doing it already 2 years, and without Google biased propoganda and manipulated censorship
Unlike illegal imigrants coming by boats - US Citizens Will Need Visa To Travel To Europe in 2024
Musk announces Twitter name and logo change to X.com
The politician and the journalist lost control and started fighting on live broadcast.
The future of sports
Unveiling the Black Hole: The Mysterious Fate of EU's Aid to Ukraine
Farewell to a Music Titan: Tony Bennett, Renowned Jazz and Pop Vocalist, Passes Away at 96
Alarming Behavior Among Florida's Sharks Raises Concerns Over Possible Cocaine Exposure
Transgender Exclusion in Miss Italy Stirs Controversy Amidst Changing Global Beauty Pageant Landscape
Joe Biden admitted, in his own words, that he delivered what he promised in exchange for the $10 million bribe he received from the Ukraine Oil Company.
TikTok Takes On Spotify And Apple, Launches Own Music Service
Global Trend: Using Anti-Fake News Laws as Censorship Tools - A Deep Dive into Tunisia's Scenario
Arresting Putin During South African Visit Would Equate to War Declaration, Asserts President Ramaphosa
Hacktivist Collective Anonymous Launches 'Project Disclosure' to Unearth Information on UFOs and ETIs
Typo sends millions of US military emails to Russian ally Mali
Server Arrested For Theft After Refusing To Pay A Table's $100 Restaurant Bill When They Dined & Dashed
The Changing Face of Europe: How Mass Migration is Reshaping the Political Landscape
China Urges EU to Clarify Strategic Partnership Amid Trade Tensions
The Last Pour: Anchor Brewing, America's Pioneer Craft Brewer, Closes After 127 Years
Democracy not: EU's Digital Commissioner Considers Shutting Down Social Media Platforms Amid Social Unrest
Sarah Silverman and Renowned Authors Lodge Copyright Infringement Case Against OpenAI and Meta
Why Do Tech Executives Support Kennedy Jr.?
The New York Times Announces Closure of its Sports Section in Favor of The Athletic
BBC Anchor Huw Edwards Hospitalized Amid Child Sex Abuse Allegations, Family Confirms
Florida Attorney General requests Meta CEO's testimony on company's platforms' alleged facilitation of illicit activities
The Distorted Mirror of actual approval ratings: Examining the True Threat to Democracy Beyond the Persona of Putin
40,000 child slaves in Congo are forced to work in cobalt mines so we can drive electric cars.