Hong Kong News

Nonpartisan, Noncommercial, unconstrained.
Friday, Mar 29, 2024

Hong Kong judge weighs whether animals have right to sue in judicial review case

Hong Kong judge weighs whether animals have right to sue in judicial review case

The pet owner seeking the review had adopted one of 30 pets found at the base of a local housing block last year after they apparently had been thrown from a height.

A Hong Kong judge questioned on Monday whether animals had the right to sue after a woman who adopted one of 30 pets thrown from a building last year challenged prosecutors’ decision not to press charges against the two alleged perpetrators.

Mr Justice Alex Lee Wan-tang raised the question after the adoptive owner argued that prosecutors had a duty to explain their decisions in cases involving animals as victims.

In an application for a judicial review, barrister Kim McCoy argued there were exceptional circumstances that warranted clarification in the present case, given the immense public interest it generated after the animals were found dead or severely injured at the bottom of the Hong Kong Garden housing estate, near Sham Tseng, on February 14, 2020.

“There is a necessity for the Department of Justice to give proper reasons [for its decision not to prosecute],” McCoy argued. “The public wants and requires accountability.”

His client, Pang Lok-sze, and her boyfriend adopted one of the 12 surviving pets, a British shorthair cat they named Potter, a day after the department revealed on September 2 – in response to media enquiries – that it would not prosecute the two men investigated due to insufficient evidence. The 18 other animals involved, which included birds and rodents, were killed in the incident.

The decision sparked outrage among pet owners and animal rights groups, as it was widely reported that the men had surrendered themselves to police. The department last month clarified that the men had not turned themselves in and admitted charges as reported. However, questions remained as to whether the director of public prosecutions had a duty to inform the public about his decisions in a timely manner to allow those inclined to pursue private prosecutions to do so within the statutory time limit.

McCoy argued the director had a duty to communicate and explain his decision to the public when the case involved immense public interest and a significant number of victims who were incapable of exercising their rights – a class that includes not only animals, but also children and mentally incapacitated people.

Pang’s challenge also raised what McCoy described as a “very novel” question about who could apply for a judicial review when the victims were animals with no standing of their own under Hong Kong law.

McCoy argued that Pang had a direct and sufficient interest to bring the judicial challenge as a result of her adoption, giving her equal standing to the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA), which dealt with all 30 animals and assisted police investigations, but decided against challenging the decision not to prosecute.

The judge questioned whether animals had the right to sue in the first place, and if not, how an adoption could change that status and confer the right on their adoptive owners.

McCoy agreed that Potter could not take legal action himself, but could do so with a representative such as his adoptive owner, just as a foster parent could bring proceedings on behalf of a child in their care upon learning he or she had been previously abused.

Senior assistant law officer William Liu Kwun-wa countered that Potter could not be considered a victim as the term related to a person, while animals were regarded as property under Hong Kong law.

Liu further submitted that Pang did not have sufficient interest to apply for a judicial review when the SPCA was better placed to take action, adding that her proposed grounds of challenge were not reasonably arguable.

He said the director had no duty to inform the public, and added that one did not have to wait for his decision to start a private prosecution.

The counsel also argued that the director’s decision could only be challenged in very limited circumstances, since the Basic Law, the city’s mini-constitution, provided that the department “shall control criminal prosecutions, free from any interference”. In this case, Liu said, the court could only intervene when the decision was unconstitutional.

But he conceded that the department did not clarify media reports that may have led the public to think that suspects who had admitted their guilt were not being prosecuted.

Lee, the judge, said it was “unfortunate” that prosecutors had not corrected the inaccurate reports.

“I’m not trying to criticise anyone,” he added. “If a statement had been made, maybe we would not be here.”

Lee will hand down his judgment at a later date.

Newsletter

Related Articles

Hong Kong News
0:00
0:00
Close
It's always the people with the dirty hands pointing their fingers
Paper straws found to contain long-lasting and potentially toxic chemicals - study
FTX's Bankman-Fried headed for jail after judge revokes bail
Blackrock gets half a trillion dollar deal to rebuild Ukraine
Steve Jobs' Son Launches Venture Capital Firm With $200 Million For Cancer Treatments
Google reshuffles Assistant unit, lays off some staffers, to 'supercharge' products with A.I.
End of Viagra? FDA approved a gel against erectile dysfunction
UK sanctions Russians judges over dual British national Kara-Murza's trial
US restricts visa-free travel for Hungarian passport holders because of security concerns
America's First New Nuclear Reactor in Nearly Seven Years Begins Operations
Southeast Asia moves closer to economic unity with new regional payments system
Political leader from South Africa, Julius Malema, led violent racist chants at a massive rally on Saturday
Today Hunter Biden’s best friend and business associate, Devon Archer, testified that Joe Biden met in Georgetown with Russian Moscow Mayor's Wife Yelena Baturina who later paid Hunter Biden $3.5 million in so called “consulting fees”
'I am not your servant': IndiGo crew member, passenger get into row over airline meal
Singapore Carries Out First Execution of a Woman in Two Decades Amid Capital Punishment Debate
Spanish Citizenship Granted to Iranian chess player who removed hijab
US Senate Republican Mitch McConnell freezes up, leaves press conference
Speaker McCarthy says the United States House of Representatives is getting ready to impeach Joe Biden.
San Francisco car crash
This camera man is a genius
3D ad in front of Burj Khalifa
Next level gaming
BMW driver…
Google testing journalism AI. We are doing it already 2 years, and without Google biased propoganda and manipulated censorship
Unlike illegal imigrants coming by boats - US Citizens Will Need Visa To Travel To Europe in 2024
Musk announces Twitter name and logo change to X.com
The politician and the journalist lost control and started fighting on live broadcast.
The future of sports
Unveiling the Black Hole: The Mysterious Fate of EU's Aid to Ukraine
Farewell to a Music Titan: Tony Bennett, Renowned Jazz and Pop Vocalist, Passes Away at 96
Alarming Behavior Among Florida's Sharks Raises Concerns Over Possible Cocaine Exposure
Transgender Exclusion in Miss Italy Stirs Controversy Amidst Changing Global Beauty Pageant Landscape
Joe Biden admitted, in his own words, that he delivered what he promised in exchange for the $10 million bribe he received from the Ukraine Oil Company.
TikTok Takes On Spotify And Apple, Launches Own Music Service
Global Trend: Using Anti-Fake News Laws as Censorship Tools - A Deep Dive into Tunisia's Scenario
Arresting Putin During South African Visit Would Equate to War Declaration, Asserts President Ramaphosa
Hacktivist Collective Anonymous Launches 'Project Disclosure' to Unearth Information on UFOs and ETIs
Typo sends millions of US military emails to Russian ally Mali
Server Arrested For Theft After Refusing To Pay A Table's $100 Restaurant Bill When They Dined & Dashed
The Changing Face of Europe: How Mass Migration is Reshaping the Political Landscape
China Urges EU to Clarify Strategic Partnership Amid Trade Tensions
The Last Pour: Anchor Brewing, America's Pioneer Craft Brewer, Closes After 127 Years
Democracy not: EU's Digital Commissioner Considers Shutting Down Social Media Platforms Amid Social Unrest
Sarah Silverman and Renowned Authors Lodge Copyright Infringement Case Against OpenAI and Meta
Why Do Tech Executives Support Kennedy Jr.?
The New York Times Announces Closure of its Sports Section in Favor of The Athletic
BBC Anchor Huw Edwards Hospitalized Amid Child Sex Abuse Allegations, Family Confirms
Florida Attorney General requests Meta CEO's testimony on company's platforms' alleged facilitation of illicit activities
The Distorted Mirror of actual approval ratings: Examining the True Threat to Democracy Beyond the Persona of Putin
40,000 child slaves in Congo are forced to work in cobalt mines so we can drive electric cars.
×